When seemingly every boy in school gets a shot at ice skating with Trixie at the local ice rink before he, Timmy wishes that he and Trixie were the last two people on Earth. At first, Timmy enjoys the attention Trixie is giving him, but soon the lack of people cause Trixie, who is used to having hundreds of people adoring her at once, to crave Timmy's attention non-stop. Timmy must do what he'd never thought he'd do, and dump Trixie, so that he could unwish the wish and return her and everyone else to normal. Unfortunately for Timmy, Trixie may not be willing to take the news so lightly!